SUU ENGL 1010: Introduction to Academic Writing

Project II: A River Runs Through It

 

This novel set in Montana focuses on fly fishing and the relationship between two brothers who try to answer most of life's problems by taking each other fishing.
 

Due dates: Workshop: Oct. 3; Final draft: Oct. 10

Purpose:

Audience: You will assume an educated general audience eager to understand your core beliefs and values.

Craft topics:   To revisit: audience, "confusable" words,  dialogue; To introduce: comma splices, comparison/contrast, definition, development, fragments, narrative

Format: After stating your thesis in terms of a belief statement, you may explain your reasons in essay style or develop a narrative that makes your point. 

250 Total Points including the following: Essay (150); Cover memo (5); Workshop with draft (10); daily work folder (85)

 

 

 You may use informal narration and description patterns for this essay or the more formal genres that follow analogy, definition, or comparison/contrast  organizations.

 


Study Question Procedures:

 

First section

Respond to ONE of these questions with a SUBSTANTIAL paragraph or two of  125-250 words (about 1/2-1page)


AIn the opening of the novel, Maclean defines fly fishing as a religion.  What characteristics do fly fishing and his  religious practice have in common in the author's mind?  Is there any activity or a ritual that you might define as akin to a religious practice in your family or personal life?  Which character traits or values does this activity or ritual seem to develop or suppress. Explain.

B. Maclean loves his brother, but are the two really very much alike? Compare what they have in common and contrast the characteristics they do not share.



Second section

Respond to ONE of these questions with a short essay of  125-250 words

(about 1/2-1 page)

As I've been rereading this novel, I've been wondering about the way Maclean portrays women in the book. In what ways does his portrait of "Old Rawhide" seem to draw from and/or break stereotypes about "bad" women. The virtuous Scottish women in Maclean's life contrast greatly with Old Rawhide, but might they be as stuck in a stereotypical role as much as Old Rawhide? What do you think--does Maclean tend to flatten out and simplify his pictures of women or does he present them as fully developed characters? Explain.
Why do the brothers have such contempt for Neal? What are his vices? What does Maclean's presentation of those vices show about his values? Do you agree with those values? Why?


Third section

Respond to ONE of these questions with a short essay of  125-250 words (about 1/2-1page)


A. What scenes in the book show the love between Maclean and his brother? What scenes show the tension? Write a description of one to three events that could illustrate to a reader who doesn't know you what kind of relationship you share with a family member or a friend.

B. What makes Paul an artist? Why can't he, despite his great power as a fisherman and his ability to enter fully into the natural world, find peace and happiness?




Fourth section

Respond to ONE of these questions with a short essay of  125-250 words (about 1/2-1page)


A. One of the book's most important themes focuses on Maclean's frustration as he tries to find ways to help his doomed brother. Do you agree or disagree with his assertion that it is rare that we can really help one another? Do you think Maclean's vision of  the interaction of help with independence is tied to a gendered or maybe geographical (Western) view of the world? What in the book supports and/or undercuts Maclean's argument? What experiences in your own life lead you to agree or disagree, especially as they relate to the person you intend to write about.


B. Why does Maclean take his brother fishing when he doesn't know what else to do for him? What have you done in similar situations? How is your notion of what's appropriate to do for someone in trouble influenced by your gender or religious and or ethnic affiliations?

C. What for Maclean does the river seem to represent? Can immersion in nature save us, in Maclean's view? If so, why doesn't Paul's love of  the wilderness save him? If not, why does Maclean express such an aching love for the Montana landscape? And why is he able to bring himself to leave it, when his brother cannot?